Saturday, May 1, 2010

Star Wars: From Best to Worst

A thread on the Star Wars saga has already been done, but i'd like to put in my two cents on the matter.

1. The Empire Strikes Back - It goes without saying. Not since Frances Coppola's The Godfather Part II has there been a sequel that stands alone as a separate work from it's predecessor. The end result in Empire is now a standard in any sequel: the bad guys get the win, leaving our heroes to regroup, lick their wounds, and get ready for the next battle. Billy Dee Williams as Lando, and the majestic Frank Oz as Master Yoda are the standouts of this dark, thrilling chapter of the saga.

2. Revenge of the Sith - Lucas saved the best of the Star Wars prequel trilogy for last - and with it, the series itself. After the silliness of Phantom Menace and the dreadful love story that was Attack of the Clones, George goes for broke, adds the elements of what made Episode V a classic, and goes one better - he makes the last hour of the saga from exciting, sci-fi fare, to Shakespearean tragedy as Anakin succumbs to the Dark Side and becomes the evil Darth Vader.

3. A New Hope - Of course, this also goes without saying. Episode IV was the film that started it all. The reason why generations of adults geek out whenever we hear John William's timeless opening theme on television.

4. The Phantom Menace - Episode I gets so much shit from the fans, and to a good extent, the fans are right on: Its the silliest of the lot and it includes the worst character since the Ewokes in Episode VI with the awful Jar-Jar Binks (George Lucas, what the hell were you smoking when you brought this blubbering idiot to life!?). But Phantom Menace, I now realize, wasn't supposed to be made for the old-time fans. This was made to bring in a new generation of Star Wars geeks who'll dress up in Jedi and Clone-trooper outfits every year at Comic-Con in San Diego. Plus, it was fun as hell to watch Darth Maul whip out his double-headed lightsaber and cause havoc for the Jedi.

5. Return of the Jedi - Much like The Godfather Part III, we went in with high hopes and ambitions that the final installment would do one better than its predecessors A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. What we got were primitive teddy bear warriors and a party on their planet after the Emperor and his second Death Star are destroyed.

6. Attack of the Clones - The worst one. I hated how this became a sappy, romantic melodrama in space, rather than a mysterious, dark insallment of how Palpatine plays both the Jedi Knights and the Separatists as pawns in his quest for galactic dominance. Plus, Hayden Christensen (sp?) made Anakin a whiny, annoying bitch, rather than a doomed, though sympathetic figure. Not even credible actors like Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Christopher Lee, and Samuel L. Jackson could save this pathetic installment from going up in flames.

2 comments:

Count Istvan said...

I did this list somewhere on here. :)

et said...

I think - and I am a SW geek of yore, of the first order: I can tell you, for instance, from memory, that the odds of successfully navigating an asteroid field are approximately 3,720 to one! - that it would be fairer to bump Jedi up above Phantom Menace in Jonathan's calculus.

Notwithstanding Lucas' impetus to draw in a fresh, new audience, PM was a clunker in film-making terms. The success it achieved was thanks to its pedigree. It had inspiring vistas and out-there costumes, yes, but it also had a story-line shoehorned to fill in the gaps of a history that I firmly believe GL constructed after the fact, rather than envisioned, in whole cloth, from the get-go. Pod-racing. Give me a break. Has the man never gotten past "American Graffiti"? All that saves this film for me are the performances of McGregor and Neeson, troupers both.

And don't get me started on the pestilence that is the existence of Jar-Jar Binks in the collective unconscious. George, wake up. Don't take your character cues from your adopted preschoolers. That way lies Barney.

What I think bumps Jedi up the scale is that if you follow the Luke/Vader story - not the Ewok travesty or Harrison Ford mugging his way shamelessly through his every line of that film - it actually completes a mythic storytelling arc. The son confronting and differentiating himself from the father, and then the extra twist of that father rising to the defense of the son, against what you could argue was his own "spiritual" father in the form of the Emperor. I remember being in the theatre on opening night, and the sea change in the audience when they suddenly began rooting for Vader at the very end. Now, THAT is movie-making at its best.

If I'm being honest? I would have probably preferred no prequels at all, to what we were served up. And I say that as a fan.

Total Pageviews